← Back to Home

The Third Temptation

WHAT THIS TIMELINE MEASURES: A single, specific question across 2,000 years:
"How closely did this movement follow Christ's example of rejecting political power to advance God's kingdom?"

⚠️ IMPORTANT: The scores below measure ONLY the willingness to use political/state power to advance Christianity.
They do NOT evaluate: personal holiness, theological accuracy, evangelistic zeal, love for enemies, sexual ethics, charitable works, or any other Christian virtue.

Example: Charlie Kirk receives a low score (2.5) for seeking political power to advance Christianity—but if we measured his commitment to traditional marriage, love for enemies, or personal sacrifice, he would score much higher. Similarly, movements with high scores here might fail on other biblical measures.

The Single Criterion: When offered earthly power to accomplish God's purposes, did they say "Away with you, Satan!" like Christ did, or did they grasp the crown?

From Christ's rejection of Satan's offer to rule all kingdoms, to today's fusion of faith and politics.
Each movement is scored 0-10 based solely on this one aspect: refusing vs. seeking political power for spiritual ends.

~30 AD

The Original Victory: Christ's Temptation

Foundation Spiritual Warfare Kingdom Rejection
Jesus rejects Satan's offer of all earthly kingdoms, establishing the eternal principle: "My kingdom is not of this world." This becomes the cosmic template—spiritual transformation through suffering and service, not political power.
"All these I will give you, if you will fall down and worship me." — Matthew 4:9

"Away with you, Satan!" — Jesus' response

"My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, my servants would fight, so that I should not be delivered to the Jews; but now my kingdom is not from here." — John 18:36
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
10
250-350 AD

The Desert Fathers & Mothers

Withdrawal Asceticism Spiritual Purity
As Christianity becomes fashionable and wealthy under Constantine, thousands flee to Egyptian and Syrian deserts. Anthony, Pachomius, and Mary of Egypt seek God in poverty and solitude, rejecting the church's newfound power. Their witness: true Christianity cannot be wedded to empire.
"I saw the snares that the enemy spreads out over the world and I said groaning, 'What can get through from such snares?' Then I heard a voice saying to me, 'Humility.'" — Anthony the Great
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8.5
312-337 AD

The Constantinian Shift

Imperial Power State Religion Theological Crisis
Christianity transforms from persecuted minority to imperial religion. The church gains palaces but loses prophetic distance. Bishops become courtiers; the cross becomes a sword. The fusion of spiritual and temporal authority begins.
"In this sign, conquer" — Constantine's vision before the Battle of Milvian Bridge
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
2.5
4th-5th Century

The Donatist Resistance

Church Purity State Resistance African Christianity
North African Christians reject imperial interference in church affairs. They refuse clergy who compromised during persecution and resist Constantine's demand for unity. The empire responds with force. Their witness: the state cannot dictate faith, and political unity is not worth spiritual compromise.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
7.5
800 AD

Charlemagne's Holy Roman Empire

Forced Conversion Theocratic Empire Sword Evangelism
Pope Leo III crowns Charlemagne, creating explicit fusion of church and state. Saxon tribes face conversion or death. The Gospel spreads at sword-point—a complete inversion of Christ's way.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
1.5
1075-1122

The Investiture Controversy

Papal Supremacy Imperial Authority Power Struggle
Pope Gregory VII claims power to depose emperors; Emperor Henry IV claims right to appoint bishops. The church doesn't reject worldly power—it claims ultimate authority over it. Both sides grasp for the crown Christ refused.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
2
1095-1291

The Crusades

Holy War Salvation Through Violence Indulgences
Pope Urban II promises salvation for those who kill for Christ. The cross becomes a battle standard. Jerusalem is conquered with rivers of blood. The Prince of Peace's message drowns in violence committed in his name.
"God wills it!" — Battle cry of the Crusaders
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
0.5
1170s-Present

The Waldensian Witness

Apostolic Poverty Biblical Authority Centuries of Persecution
Peter Waldo and followers embrace radical poverty, reject papal authority, and preach in common language. Persecuted for 800 years—surviving in Alpine valleys through massacres, crusades, and inquisitions. They maintain separation from state power, influencing later reformers. "The Light Shines in Darkness."
"Lux lucet in tenebris" (Light shines in darkness) — Waldensian motto
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8
1457-1620s

The Bohemian Brethren: Hus's Legacy

Pacifism Biblical Authority Simple Living
Born from Jan Hus's martyrdom, the Unity of the Brethren reject violence, oaths, and political authority. They create the first Protestant hymnal, practice church discipline, and emphasize practical Christianity. Despite fierce persecution—forced underground after the Battle of White Mountain—they maintain their witness. Their remnant will later birth the Moravian renewal.
"The essential thing is not to conquer but to endure" — Bohemian Brethren saying

"We have determined to follow Christ in poverty, reproach, and persecution" — Early confession
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8.5
1200s

Francis of Assisi & Early Franciscans

Radical Poverty Peace Making Creation Care
Francis renounces wealth, embraces lepers, and calls followers to be "lesser brothers." He walks unarmed into the Sultan's camp during the Crusades, seeking peace not conquest. The early Franciscans reject property and power, though later generations compromise. Francis shows another way is possible.
"Lord, make me an instrument of your peace" — Attributed to Francis

"Preach the Gospel at all times. When necessary, use words."
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
9
1370s-1400s

John Wycliffe & the Lollards

Scripture Translation Church Poverty Anti-Temporal Power
Wycliffe challenges church wealth and temporal authority, translates Bible into English. Lollards continue his work despite persecution—many burned at the stake. They reject the church's civil power and argue clergy should own no property. Seeds of reformation planted in blood.
"Christ during His life upon earth was of all men the poorest" — John Wycliffe
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
7.5
1517-1648

Protestant Reformation & Wars of Religion

Cuius regio, eius religio State Churches Religious Wars
Reformation begins with spiritual renewal but devolves into political fragmentation. Princes choose their subjects' faith. Thirty Years' War devastates Europe. Christ's kingdom splinters into competing state churches, each claiming divine mandate.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
3
1525-1660s

The Anabaptist Witness: Radical Separation

Martyrdom Nonresistance Voluntary Faith True Separation
While Christendom wages war, Anabaptists choose the way of Christ. They reject infant baptism, refuse the sword, and separate church from state entirely. Thousands are drowned, burned, and beheaded by both Catholics and Protestants. Their blood becomes the seed of religious liberty—influencing Roger Williams, William Penn, and through them, the American principle of church-state separation.
"Our kingdom is not of this world, therefore we cannot fight with the sword." — Conrad Grebel

"True Christians use neither worldly sword nor engage in war." — Schleitheim Confession, 1527
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
9
1642-1660

Puritan Commonwealth

Theocratic Experiment Moral Legislation Divine Right
Oliver Cromwell attempts to create God's kingdom through military might and legislation. Parliament abolished, theaters closed, Christmas banned. The "New Jerusalem" built with iron fist rather than servant's towel.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
2.5
1650s-1700s

The Quaker Testimony

Inner Light Peace Testimony Religious Liberty
Friends refuse oaths, titles, and violence. Persecuted in England and Massachusetts Bay, they establish Pennsylvania as "Holy Experiment" in religious freedom. William Penn's Frame of Government separates religious and civil spheres. Their suffering and witness help birth American religious liberty.
"We utterly deny all outward wars and strife and fightings with outward weapons, for any end or under any pretence whatsoever" — Peace Testimony, 1661
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8.5
1727-Present

The Moravian Revival: Prayer and Mission

Continuous Prayer Global Missions Christian Unity
Under Count Zinzendorf, refugees from the Bohemian Brethren experience Pentecost-like renewal at Herrnhut. They launch a 100-year prayer meeting (1727-1827) and send missionaries worldwide—more in 20 years than Protestantism had sent in 200. Avoiding political power, they focus on heart religion, Christian unity, and reaching the marginalized. Their witness influences Wesley, sparking Methodist revival.
"I have but one passion: It is He, it is He alone" — Count Zinzendorf

"In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things love" — Moravian motto
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8
1620-1790s

American Colonial Theocracies

City Upon a Hill Puritan Experiment Religious Establishment
Massachusetts Bay Colony attempts "holy commonwealth." Church membership required for voting. Dissenters banished or executed. The American experiment begins with fusion of civil and religious authority—later rejected by the Founders.
"We shall be as a city upon a hill" — John Winthrop
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
3.5
1890s-1933

Social Gospel & Prohibition

Progressive Christianity Moral Legislation Kingdom Through Law
The Social Gospel seeks Kingdom of God through social reform and legislation. Prohibition becomes the ultimate test—attempting to legislate righteousness. It fails catastrophically, proving again that spiritual transformation cannot be achieved through civil law.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
4.5
1933-1945

The Confessing Church

Nazi Resistance Barmen Declaration Martyrdom
German Christians reject Nazi control of the church. The Barmen Declaration asserts Christ's sole lordship over the church. Bonhoeffer, executed days before liberation, shows the cost of resistance. While many churches bow to the state, the Confessing Church stands—and suffers.
"Jesus Christ, as he is attested for us in Holy Scripture, is the one Word of God which we have to hear and which we have to trust and obey in life and in death." — Barmen Declaration

"When Christ calls a man, he bids him come and die." — Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8
1950s-1960s

Civil Rights Movement: Prophetic Challenge

Nonviolent Resistance Federal Intervention Legislative Justice
While King demonstrated Christ-like compassion for the oppressed and maintained nonviolence, his methodology fundamentally differed from Christ's example. Christ never petitioned Rome for policy reforms despite witnessing severe injustice; he served the poor directly and built alternative communities. King explicitly sought federal intervention: the Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act, and later, massive government redistribution programs. The movement's strategy centered on compelling Caesar to act justly—through moral pressure, yes, but ultimately seeking political/legal solutions. Christ rejected even dialogue about political power, saying "My kingdom is not of this world."
"Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that." — Martin Luther King Jr.

"A society that has done something special against the Negro for hundreds of years must now do something special for the Negro" — King explicitly calling for government action
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
4.5
1960s-1980s

Liberation Theology

Revolutionary Christianity Marxist Alliance Justice Through Revolution
Latin American churches embrace political revolution as path to Gospel justice. Some align with Marxist movements. The oppressed become oppressors. Violence sanctified for social change—the temptation repackaged as liberation.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
4
1960s-1980s

Base Ecclesial Communities

Grassroots Faith Peaceful Justice Option for Poor
Small Catholic communities in Latin America read Scripture, serve the poor, and seek justice—but largely reject violent revolution. Unlike mainstream Liberation Theology, they emphasize spiritual transformation and community organizing over political power. Many face persecution from both right-wing governments and revolutionary movements.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
7
1979-2020s

The Moral Majority

Religious Right Culture Wars Electoral Politics
Jerry Falwell launches movement to "reclaim America for Christ" through electoral politics. Evangelicals become a voting bloc. Spiritual revival conflated with political victory. The kingdom of God reduced to ballot initiatives and Supreme Court appointments.
"Get them saved, baptized, and registered to vote" — Jerry Falwell
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
3
1950s-Present

Chinese House Churches

Underground Faith State Persecution Spiritual Independence
Millions of Chinese Christians worship in secret rather than join the state-controlled Three-Self Patriotic Movement. They choose persecution—imprisonment, torture, death—over letting the Communist Party dictate their faith. The underground church grows explosively while maintaining complete separation from state power.
"I would rather go to prison than deny my faith" — Pastor Wang Yi, sentenced to 9 years
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
8.5
2000s-2025

Global Religious Nationalism

State Churches Religious Nationalism Authoritarian Alliance
Orthodox Church merges with Putin's state. Polish Catholic nationalism rises. Brazilian evangelicals seek power. Hindu nationalism in India. The global church increasingly embraces strongmen who promise Christian dominance.
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
2
September 10, 2025
Martyrdom Politics Seven Mountains Church-State Fusion
Kirk explicitly rejected church-state separation, calling it "a fabrication." His death transforms him into a "martyr" for Christian nationalism. Churches declare his killing an attack on Christianity itself. Political violence becomes spiritual warfare. The fusion of throne and altar reaches its apex—or nadir.
"There is no separation of church and state" — Charlie Kirk, 2022

"I want to be remembered for courage for my faith" — Kirk's final interview, June 2025
Alignment with Christ's Rejection of Earthly Power
✗ Unlike Christ ✓ Like Christ
2.5

About This Project

Created by Eugene Ulrich

I welcome your feedback on this timeline, especially regarding how fairly and accurately it represents these historical movements and their relationship to Christ's rejection of earthly power.

Does this fairly represent history through current events? Let me know:

📱 Call/Text: 817-907-1029 ✉️ Email: emailme@thisinbox.com

Your perspectives, corrections, and insights are valued—especially from those whose traditions are represented here.